Connect with us


Semper Dry: Now Marines Can Carry Umbrellas, Setting Off Stormy Debate


Semper Dry: Now Marines Can Carry Umbrellas, Setting Off Stormy Debate

For hundreds of years, Marines have endured the elements. The official uniform regulations are crammed with rules about how hair should be parted and what color socks are allowed with combat boots. They also made clear most Marines weren’t allowed to carry an umbrella.

In an about-face, the service retreated from the ban last week, kicking off a debate within the Marine Corps—America’s bastion of good order and discipline—about whether the idea was all wet.

Weather or not

“A Marine cannot choke an enemy or properly punch him in the face with an umbrella in his hand,” said Shane Witcher, 56, a former sergeant who now lives in Bastrop, Texas, and served as a Marine mortarman, in a


post. In an interview, he added, “We are always at the ready and it just goes against the grain of that very philosophy to have an umbrella in your hand.”

On the other side is Maximilian Uriarte, a Marine veteran in Burbank, Calif., and artist behind “Terminal Lance,” a comic strip that revels in the everyday preposterousness of Marine Corps life.

“I always applaud the progress of removing stupid rules that shouldn’t have existed in the first place,” he said.

“UMBRELLAS,” now reads paragraph 3035 of the uniform regulations. “Marines may carry an all-black, plain, standard or collapsible umbrella at their option during inclement weather with the service and dress uniforms.”

Marines out in the field or in battle, wearing their camouflage utilities, still won’t be toting umbrellas alongside their rifles and rucksacks. And Marines in formation will likely still be braving the elements. Umbrellas are only permitted with the green service uniform (the military equivalent of a business suit) and dress blues, for occasions such as working in a headquarters or on recruiting duty, or for formal dinners.

Marines have other rules that cause consternation among the rank and file: They can’t wear white socks with combat boots, or keep their hands in their pockets.

U.S. Marine recruits held their issued black socks up in the air as they begin boot camp at Parris Island, S.C.


Stephen Morton/Getty Images

Female Marines were given permission to use umbrellas back in 1972. Officials couldn’t say why the rules changed for women but not men, though some guessed it came down to men wanting to appear rugged and stoic.

Since then, six efforts to grant men the same precipitation protection have been proposed. All were shot down along the way, said Mary Boyt, program manager for the Marine Corps Uniform Board, the official gatekeepers for any changes.

A recent survey of Marines found that 76% of men and 94% of women said umbrellas should be allowed, Ms. Boyt said. “I can’t tell you why it got approved this time around,” she added, but many said they supported it not necessarily to help soggy Marines but to preserve their natty uniforms.

Marines looking for rain protection can in most situations turn to a trench coat derisively known as the Inspector Gadget, for its resemblance to one worn by the bumbling 1980s cartoon detective. Many won’t wear the coat, even in rain, and promptly lose it after it is issued.

The umbrella rule change came just days before the Marine Corps’ birthday on Nov. 10, the holiest day on the Corps’ calendar.

On Friday night in Chicago, hundreds of Jarheads gathered at the Old Crow Smokehouse near Wrigley Field for an early birthday ball celebration.

“We should have umbrellas. It’s common sense,” said Cpl. Jose Hernandez, a reservist decked out in dress blues and gleaming ribbons, who said he’d rather get rained on than wear the standard-issue trench coat. “To be honest, the Inspector Gadget is pretty ugly.”

As he laid out his reasoning, Lance Cpl. Dylan Mendoza broke in.

A Step-By-Step Blueprint For Making Money Online, That Is 100% Dummy Proof!


Get The Simple Traffic Blueprint Now!

“What if you need both hands?” he asked, turning to the corporal then waving one hand around wildly. His other hand remained stock still as it cradled his pristine white dress cap.

President Trump leaving his umbrella on the steps of Marine One last year.


kevin lamarque/Reuters

Watching the exchange was Cpl. Aaron Gibbs, an active duty Marine whose dress blues, above-average height and sharp haircut served him well for carrying a flag in the evening’s ceremonies.

Without blinking, he said he does what the Marine Corps tells him. “If they say have an umbrella, I get an umbrella. If they say no, then no,” he said. “It’s just walking outside.”

The Army, Navy and Air Force have long authorized umbrellas for use by both sexes, and while officials declined to say why the Marines have waited so long, many Marines said they revel in being miserable and love having something to complain about.


You’re a Marine and it’s raining. Do you grab an umbrella? Join the conversation below.

“There’s inherent training value to expose ourselves to misery, so when the time comes it will be second nature to us,” said the former mortarman, Mr. Witcher.

A 2013 incident involving then-President Barack Obama seemed to cement the umbrella’s fate. At a press conference, a Marine in blues held an umbrella over the president as he spoke. The incident, known by some Marines to this day as Umbrellagate, rained criticism on Mr. Obama for appearing to not know, or care to follow, Marine Corps protocol.

Mr. Obama didn’t respond to a request for comment.

The modern umbrella is linked to rainy England and 18th-century philanthropist Jonas Hanway, reputed to be the first man to carry one in London, according to a biography compiled by Westminster Abbey, where he is buried.

The martial history of umbrellas is harder to pin down. Brolliology—the study of umbrellas—isn’t a popular academic pursuit. One story involves the Duke of Wellington, who defeated Napoleon at Waterloo.

Former United States Marine Tim Chambers held a salute in the rain during the Rolling Thunder Memorial Day motorcycle rally in 2017.


pete marovich/European Pressphoto Agency

“Lord Wellington does not approve of the use of umbrellas during the enemy’s firing, and will not allow ‘the gentlemen’s sons’ to make themselves ridiculous in the eyes of the enemy,” a Captain Gronow recalled, according to the Oxford Book of Military Anecdotes. (Wellington said guards on duty at St. James were allowed to carry umbrellas if they pleased.)

Today, the Marine Corps Uniform Board meets regularly to consider and propose changes. In May, along with the umbrella ban, board members discussed other issues such as whether Marines can tailor their dress shirts to be more form-fitting. They are now allowed to do so.

A closer look at recent uniform regulations show that other cracks are appearing in the facade, including what appears to be tacit permission for Leathernecks to keep their hands in their pockets.

“In a garrison environment you may not put your hands in your pockets other than to retrieve something from said pockets, at any time,” the uniform board website says. “However, good judgment will govern the application of this policy in the field environment.”

Write to Ben Kesling at

Copyright ©2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Free Gift With Our Newsletter

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe

Top Stories!

To Top